⚠️ Turbulence Ahead: CRE Q3 Earnings and Forecasts

Good morning,

Turbulence ahead: CRE Q3 earnings and forecasts; S&P 500 sees earnings rebound, broader market surges as consumer spending lifts earnings; and Google abandons $15 billion bay area real estate project. Let’s delve into today’s topics.

📈 Market Update

⚠️ Turbulence Ahead: CRE Q3 Earnings and Forecasts

CRE industry is facing a downturn, as evidenced by the third-quarter earnings reports from industry giants CBRE Group, Cushman & Wakefield, and Marcus & Millichap. CBRE reported a significant 57.3% drop in net income and reductions in key revenue streams, while Cushman & Wakefield experienced a 9% fall in revenue and a net loss of $33.9 million. Marcus & Millichap also reported a third-quarter loss of $9.2 million, reversing a profit from the same quarter last year. All three companies noted a decrease in transactional activities, highlighting a trend of reduced property and financing deals. Increased expenses for hiring and technology development have been cited, particularly by Marcus & Millichap, as factors contributing to their financial results. The overall sentiment reflects the adverse impacts of macroeconomic forces, such as higher interest rates, economic uncertainty, and changes in office space demand due to the rise of remote work.

🔍️ The Outlook:
Forecasts remain cautious, with a recovery not anticipated until at least the second half of 2024. Companies have responded with cost-cutting measures and operational efficiencies; CBRE targeted a $150 million reduction in operating costs, while Cushman & Wakefield aimed for a $130 million annual expense cut. Despite the current climate, the industry is preparing for a recalibrated market, with Marcus & Millichap not providing specific guidance but indicating a restrained transactional outlook influenced by rapid interest rate rises and tightening lending. As decision-making among occupiers remains hesitant, the larger CRE market is expected to endure a period of adjustment with a cautious eye on the evolving economic indicators and real estate usage trends.

📈 S&P 500 Sees Earnings Rebound, Broader Market Surges as Consumer Spending Lifts Earnings

The broader S&P 500 has shown signs of resilience with a 3.7% rise in earnings and a 2.3% increase in revenue during this year's third quarter, marking the first collective upswing in a year, driven largely by robust consumer spending habits. Highlighted by the strength in communication services and consumer discretionary sectors, companies such as Starbucks, Amazon, and McDonald's contributed significantly to this growth, showcasing the robustness of consumer-facing businesses

↪️ The Takeaway:
Despite the positive trends in many sectors, the commercial real estate market remains in a state of caution as the sector navigates through significant challenges. The CRE industry's giants have posted mixed results, with operational cost-cutting and efficiency drives being a common theme in response to decreased transaction activities and revenue declines. As the CRE industry braces for a prolonged period of adjustment, the spotlight turns to consumer spending patterns and their indirect impact on the market. The sector is also closely watching the performance of S&P 500 firms, hoping that the trickle-down effects of consumer expenditure might generate a ripple of positivity in the CRE domain, potentially easing some of the hesitancies seen in occupier decision-making and investment in the quarters ahead.

🚧 Google Abandons $15 Billion Bay Area Real Estate Project

Google has terminated a significant real estate development agreement with Australia's Lendlease, initially valued over $15 billion, marking a shift in its office space strategy amidst the changing workplace dynamics post-COVID-19. This decision comes as tech companies, including Google, pare down office space due to increased remote and hybrid work arrangements, contributing to the rising office vacancy rates in Silicon Valley, which hit 17% in June, up from 11% in 2019. The original plan with Lendlease aimed to develop four neighborhoods in the Bay Area, incorporating 15,000 homes and over 15 million square feet of mixed-use space. Google, which had already offered 1.3 million square feet for sublease earlier in the year, cites optimization of its real estate investments and the intention to explore other development partnerships as it continues to adapt to the new normal of workplace requirements.

✍️ Further Reading

• New Player Emerges in Slumping Finance Market, Looming Debt Due Dates Could Spur Apartment Sales, Pivot for Blackstone Office Debt in New York (CS)

• Amazon’s Jeff Bezos Announces Move to Miami From Seattle (BBG)

• Suburban Offices Embrace Amenities and Change (CPE)

• A Risk Assessment of the Office Market: Through the Lens of Bank CRE Loans (Trepp)

📊 Chart of The Day